3Hibernian wins3Draws4Heart of Midlothian wins2.5goals per game
- 26/04/26Hibernian1–2Heart of MidlothianScottish Premiership
- 10/02/26Heart of Midlothian1–0HibernianScottish Premiership
- 27/12/25Hibernian3–2Heart of MidlothianScottish Premiership
- 04/10/25Heart of Midlothian1–0HibernianScottish Premiership
- 02/03/25Hibernian2–1Heart of MidlothianScottish Premiership
- 26/12/24Heart of Midlothian1–2HibernianScottish Premiership
- 27/10/24Hibernian1–1Heart of MidlothianScottish Premiership
- 28/02/24Heart of Midlothian1–1HibernianScottish Premiership
- 27/12/23Hibernian0–1Heart of MidlothianScottish Premiership
- 07/10/23Heart of Midlothian2–2HibernianScottish Premiership