2Orlando City SC wins3Draws3FC Cincinnati wins2.6goals per game
- 15/08/26Orlando City SC1–1FC CincinnatiMLS
- 23/05/26FC Cincinnati6–2Orlando City SCMLS
- 28/09/25FC Cincinnati1–1Orlando City SCMLS
- 28/06/25Orlando City SC1–2FC CincinnatiMLS
- 05/10/24FC Cincinnati1–3Orlando City SCMLS
- 04/05/24Orlando City SC0–1FC CincinnatiMLS
- 02/09/23FC Cincinnati0–1Orlando City SCMLS
- 05/03/23Orlando City SC0–0FC CincinnatiMLS