1Waterhouse FC wins4Draws5Mount Pleasant FA wins1.6goals per game
- 28/04/26Mount Pleasant FA2–1Waterhouse FCJamaica Premier League
- 25/01/26Mount Pleasant FA0–1Waterhouse FCJamaica Premier League
- 05/10/25Waterhouse FC1–1Mount Pleasant FAJamaica Premier League
- 06/03/25Mount Pleasant FA1–0Waterhouse FCJamaica Premier League
- 29/12/24Waterhouse FC0–3Mount Pleasant FAJamaica Premier League
- 24/10/24Mount Pleasant FA0–0Waterhouse FCJamaica Premier League
- 12/05/24Mount Pleasant FA2–1Waterhouse FCJamaica Premier League
- 06/05/24Waterhouse FC1–1Mount Pleasant FAJamaica Premier League
- 03/03/24Waterhouse FC0–1Mount Pleasant FAJamaica Premier League
- 03/12/23Mount Pleasant FA0–0Waterhouse FCJamaica Premier League