Anthoni 9.0? Our index says 5.0 — the grade clash that defined Beira-Rio

Our index verdict lands where the reference never dared: Anthoni, the Internacional goalkeeper, gets a 5.0 — nowhere near the 9.0 handed out elsewhere. A four-point delta on a winning night is the loudest disagreement of the round, and our position-weighted lens is not moving.

Alan Patrick still tops our grades at 7.3, though we cool on the reference's 8.2 — solid production, not a masterpiece. The reverse holds for Matheus Bidu, whose 7.1 in our index beats his 6.6 reference mark, while Memphis Depay edges up to 6.8 against a 6.3.

The pattern is clear: the reference ran generous up and down the pitch. Kaio César 7.2 to our 6.4, Yuri Alberto 7.0 to 6.1, Raniele 7.1 to just 5.5. Our per-90 normalization keeps a 2-1 win honest — and keeps Anthoni firmly grounded at Beira-Rio.