4Everton wins2Draws2Newcastle United wins2.8goals per game
- 02/11/26Newcastle United0–1EvertonPremier League
- 28/02/26Newcastle United2–3EvertonPremier League
- 29/11/25Everton1–4Newcastle UnitedPremier League
- 25/05/25Newcastle United0–1EvertonPremier League
- 05/10/24Everton0–0Newcastle UnitedPremier League
- 02/04/24Newcastle United1–1EvertonPremier League
- 07/12/23Everton3–0Newcastle UnitedPremier League
- 27/04/23Everton1–4Newcastle UnitedPremier League